DISENCHANTED

Editorial

Dictionary

Humanity

Humor

Technology

Meta Data

Contact

Shirts, mugs

Submissions

XML feeds

LiveJournal

Search

Login

Username

Password

Save cookie

Advertising

Link to any article, and it will link back to you

Every time you visit a web page, your browser tells that page's server where you came from. Rather than a violation of privacy, it simply tells the site's owner who is sending business their way. But Disenchanted would rather not hide this information, especially if it points to a response to one of our articles. This is why every article on our site carries links back to the pages that point to them. These reciprocal links are automatic and free.

In addition to being briefly listed on our front page (in "Recent Inbound Links"), Disenchanted personally visits all pages that point to us and may write a short note that will accompany the returning link. We're not looking to insert any opinion or judgement (unless your response makes your position unambiguous) into these notes, rather we want them to tell a visitor something about the link before they click on it.

At the simplest level, you don't need to do anything beyond the act of linking itself. If you maintain your own web site, linking to an article at Disenchanted is sufficient. As soon as you (or someone else) tests that link, our page will detect, store and display the returning link. This reciprocation is permanent and shown to all other visitors - not just you.

The paragraphs themselves can link back to you

If you have a response to a specific paragraph of an article, then adding a simple argument to the end of the link address will make that paragraph link back to you. For example, let's say you're linking to "My PC, the Teenager" and you want your response to address the second paragraph. You'd link to the Disenchanted article with this URL:

http://www.disenchanted.com/dis/technology/teenage-pc.html?ref=2

The argument "?ref=2" at the end tells our page that paragraph #2 should contain a link back to your site.

The reciprocal link to your page will actually appear in a window that pops up as the reader clicks on the marker at the end of the paragraph you're linking to.

If you can't tell what number a paragraph is, just view the source code of the page in your browser. Each paragraph is numbered with an ID.

Incidentally, the IDs also give you the ability to use the indexing feature of HTML. If you take the URL from our example above and add "#2" to the end of it, then when your visitors load our page, their browser will automatically scroll down to that paragraph. See this example of the modified address:

http://www.disenchanted.com/dis/technology/teenage-pc.html?ref=2#2

For an example of this kind of linking in action, read Feedback heroin where a demonstration link was added to paragraph #2. Follow the link and you'll see how the refering page set the paragraph number in the URL it linked to.

Note: There is a bug in our implementation. If your page has two links to the same article and the first one you test links to the page in general, but the second one you test refers to a specific paragraph, then the paragraph link-back won't work (but the general one will). This may be fixed in the future.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this like Movable Type's TrackBack feature?
Yes, in a way, but TrackBack seems to solve some problems inherent in using referrers. TrackBack needs the linkee to send a “ping” to the TrackBack enabled site they're linking to. The ping is different from just following the link, and it encodes some extra information for the destination site to use. The benefits are an elimination of accidental backlinks, and the cons are that not every inbound link will be detected.

If you're looking for a Backlinking system for your own site, it may be better to try TrackBack or one of its clones becacuse it doesn't come with the administrative and filtering burden of a referrer-based system.

Using referrers as your source of backlinks can be high-maintenance.

Did you invent it?
The best answer is that since implemening it, we've found prior art.
It's not showing my page's title
We use a robot to visit your page and extract the title. This works for most sites, but if you aren't using the <title> tag properly, or there's some other issue with the markup, it may fail.
It no longer links to me
Backlinks that have “rotted” are cleaned out regularly. Sometimes we remove links to front pages with rotating content because the item of interest has disappeared into your archives. Help us rediscover those links by going to the permanent location of your archived posting and following the link back in.
How are sites picked to run on your front page?
A short list of both the most followed inbound links, and the most recent inbound links, are shown on our front page.
  • Most followed links are chosen by how many referals we've counted from that source.
  • Most recent links are chosen by how long ago the first inbound visit was detected. They rotate off the front page fairly quickly.

Links will only be featured on the front page after our robot has visited your page, verified that you are actually linking to us, and successfully extracted a title.

Can I, like, totally rip-off your idea?
Er, no. It's patented. And copyrighted. And trademarked. And we know OJ's lawyer. And the Queen mum. And the Trilateral Commission. And Eric's dad.
Can I have the source for the scripts?
Having tried twice to extract them and package them so they'd be readable, we gave up. Check the sidebar to find sites that have created scripts you can use on a variety of publishing platforms.
What should I watch out for if I build my own backlinking system?
Add a good filtering system, a verification step (check the referring page to make sure it really does have a link to you) and a moderation queue. The obvious opportunities for abuse (spamming) are being exploited. Also consider going the other way and making it TrackBack compatible.
Hi! I'm a crank selling advertising in your referrer logs! Why aren't you linking to the fine sponsor we're trying to boost the Google PageRank of?
We're pro-commerce and pro-profit. As Gordon Gekko put it, “Greed is right. Greed works.” We take the philosophy that advertising is not an evil scheme to spoil the commons, but just some guy trying to make an honest living.

That said, we aren't here to help spammers boost their PageRank. Phony referrers don't get into our site because we check for a real backlink, and even genuine backlinks can be permanently banned if we think you're only using us.

Is Disenchanted a blog?
No. However, if calling us a blog will give us lots of free publicity, then you can call us anything you like.

Last 40 responses and inbound links

(These are discovered in real-time and sorted by newest first. See how to get listed.)

  1. Automatic linkbacks [dive into mark]
  2. Backlinks For Movable Type | Pinseri
  3. sashinka | observation orientated, with a twist of lime | a blog: May 2002
  4. AutomaticLinkBack &lt; Codev &lt; TWiki
  5. Disenchanted links back to you
  6. DenkZEIT : BackLinks in Wordpress
  7. Reciprocal Links
  8. http://www.stumbleupon.com/refer.html
  9. top referrers script - geek/talk
  10. http://www.hindu.com/thehindu/biz/2002/12/02/stories/2002120200150200.htm
  11. twist of fait accomplis: Simple Backlinking with PHP
  12. Reciprocal Links
  13. Download
  14. (.*?)
  15. http://www.flutterby.com/archives/comments/4962.html
  16. (.*?)
  17. Backlinks - Waxy.org
  18. Trackback -- Seth Gordon -- ropine.com
  19. Trackback -- Seth Gordon -- ropine.com
  20. http://www.rjsjr.org/articles/bmbacklinks/
  21. (.*?)
  22. Goatee Entries January 2003
  23. Useful Books/Stuff/Web Sites
  24. http://www.hinduonnet.com/thehindu/biz/2002/12/02/stories/2002120200150200.htm
  25. Useful Books/Stuff/Web Sites
  26. Blog from August 2002 | ashbykuhlman.net
  27. Automatic linkbacks [dive into mark]
  28. Goatee Entries January 2003
  29. Goatee Entries January 2003
  30. Upcoming Article on automated back-linking
  31. Institute for War and Peace Reporting: Training Homepage
  32. http://www.vlca.net/members/
  33. Institute for War and Peace Reporting
  34. http://philringnalda.com/archives/002433.php
  35. http://www.nchicha.com/Favorites.html
  36. Reptile Rants
  37. http://www.fortytwo.uni-oldenburg.de/~hommers/
  38. http://www.myhq.com/public/z/h/zhyz/
  39. The Hindu: Logging web page backlinks
  40. http://www.worldtimzone.com/blog/date/2002/05/10

New Articles